Written by Greta Gazzaniga
The scandal in La Cronaca Grigia and the accusations against Alessandro Duroni
A recent study published an article telling a story that took place in Milan on December 11, 1864. Opening the magazine La Cronaca Grigia on that day, readers came across an article dedicated to a well-known Milanese optician and photographer, Alessandro Duroni. In this piece, the journalist Carlo Righetti discussed some photographic portraits of Alessandro Manzoni sold by Duroni; in reality, however, the article’s true intent was to expose the origins of his successful business.
The journalist described certain events that occurred during the return of the Austrians to Milan, following the brief period of the Provisional Government of Lombardy, which had been established during the revolutionary uprisings. Duroni allegedly bought up numerous 5-lira coins from 1848, working them in pairs and crafting a lid from one coin and a container from the other. In this way, he supposedly created “box-coins,” lathe-turned and equipped with a screw closure, inside of which he placed a daguerreotype of Field Marshal Radetzky. On the outside, these coins bore the legend “ITALIA LIBERA DIO LO VUOLE” (Free Italy, God wills it), while the daguerreotype accompanying the hidden image of Radetzky read “ITALIA LIBERA RADETZKY NON VOLLE” (Free Italy, Radetzky did not will it).
With this article, the journalist likely intended to expose Duroni’s opportunism, as he had allegedly profited from selling these items to Austrian officers while desecrating one of the most prominent symbols of the revolutionary period: the coins minted by the Milanese government during the time when the city was no longer under Austrian rule.
Auction 13, Lot 809, MILANO Governo provvisorio di Lombardia (1848) 5 Lire 1848 Box without daguerreotype
The photographer’s defense and the evidence of the auction lots
In response to the article, the photographer wrote a letter—published in the same magazine—in which he stated that he had indeed crafted these items, but upon the direct orders of the Austrian officers themselves, who allegedly threatened him with severe consequences if he did not comply with their demands.
This written back-and-forth does not allow us to determine which of the two versions corresponds to the truth, but it provides us with some unmistakable information regarding these objects, of which we present two specimens, respectively as lots 809 and 810 in our Numismatic Auction 13.
The first piece of data concerns the name of their maker: Alessandro Duroni, who was indeed the person who introduced the daguerreotype technique to Italy. Secondly, in his response to the journalist, the photographer claimed to have previously made similar items that contained the image of Pope Pius IX inside. This episode might explain why the Austrians turned to him for the creation of the box-coins. Duroni, however, was certainly not the only one producing objects of this kind.
Auction 13, Lot 810, MILANO Governo provvisorio di Lombardia (1848) 5 Lire 1848 Box with partially painted daguerreotype
Numismatic origins and propagandistic function
Box-coins, in fact, are nothing new in the field of numismatics. Numerous studies have explored the various meanings and symbolisms of coins, which go far beyond their strictly economic value.
The earliest box-coins date back to the 17th and 18th centuries and were produced in the German-speaking regions. Inside them, one could find small devotional miniatures or images of another kind.
By contrast, box-coins created in Italy during the years of the revolutionary uprisings served a strictly propagandistic function. Several examples of coins from those years are known in public auctions, as well as in private and public collections, that housed portraits of Charles Albert of Savoy and Pope Pius IX, both supporters of the revolutionary uprisings and aligned with anti-Austrian positions. At the time, currency was a medium of communication capable of circulating with extreme freedom. Concealing these images inside such objects made them easily accessible and within everyone’s reach.
Austrian counter-propaganda and the reuse of symbols
Box-coins featuring the image of Radetzky represent, instead, a perfect response of Austrian counter-propaganda. They removed the new revolutionary coinage from circulation and, as an additional mark of desecration, replaced previous daguerreotypes or portraits with the image of the Austrian field marshal. This choice emphasized, as suggested by the legend, that the Lombard-Venetian Kingdom remained under the control of the Austrian Empire.
The rarity of surviving daguerreotypes and lot 810
Time, however, has not been kind to these objects, precisely because of their political nature. Today, very few box-coins with portraits of Charles Albert and Pius IX have survived, likely because, after the return of the Austrians to Italy, the portraits kept inside them were destroyed. Similarly, when the Lombard-Venetian Kingdom was incorporated into the Kingdom of Italy, the portraits inside the box-coins bearing Radetzky’s image were likely destroyed as well.
Today, numerous empty box-coins exist, a circumstance that makes the specimens still retaining their original daguerreotypes particularly precious.
Indeed, between the two lots presented, only lot 810 retains a daguerreotype inside, albeit heavily damaged. The image, which has vanished in some parts, was even subjected to an attempt at repainting. These objects stand as testimony to a particularly turbulent period in Italian history and, at the same time, represent a valuable source of historical information.
Read more
- Browse the catalogue of Auction 13
- Read the news of Auction 13
- Read the blog post The Ghibelline Genovino: Genoese Coinage in the 14th Century
- Read the blog post The Mezzo Scudo of Philip II of Habsburg: a masterpiece born from failure

